Contact FreedomWorks

111 K Street NE
Suite 600
Washington, DC 20002

  • Toll Free 1.888.564.6273
  • Local 202.783.3870
LISTEN NOWNo Safe Spaces From Joe Biden's Fat Attack And Time Magazine's Madness | Pardon The Disruption Ep. #09Listen Here

Blog

Justice Clarence Thomas Takes On Civil Asset Forfeiture

In a recent statement on behalf of the US Supreme Court, Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas critiqued civil asset forfeiture and the abuses it has seen over the past several issues. In that statement, Justice Thomas said, “This system-where police can seize property with limited judicial oversight and retain it for their own use-has led to egregious and well-chronicled abuses.” The statement comes at a time when civil asset forfeiture, or the lawful seizure of assets from individuals without due process, has gained much more attention in the modern day as calls for reform have increased.

This would make this statement and the opinions of Justice Thomas very timely in relation to the greater political landscape. However, Justice Thomas is legal mind, not a political mind, so he is approaching this from a legal perspective which makes his thoughts and understanding of this all the more interesting.

To give some background, the statement was on Lisa Olivia Leonard v. Texas in which the defendant was pursuing a writ of certiorari (or judicial review) of the case. On April 1, 2013, James Leonard for pulled over for a traffic infraction in an area that was known to be a favorite spot for transporting drugs. During the investigation, the officers found a safe and during a warranted search discovered that it contained $201,000 and a bill of sale for a Pennsylvania home.

The money was then collected by the police on behalf of the state of Texas after civil asset forfeiture was authorized after arguing suspicious circumstances since James Leonard’s story changed several times during discussions with the police (eventually saying the money belonged to his mother and had been acquired by selling a home in Pennsylvania) and the Ninth District Appeals Court of Texas ruled that her testimony was insufficient to declare her an innocent owner. Her case for certiorari was eventually denied by the Supreme Court, but during the statement denying certiorari, Justice Thomas was able to give his thoughts on civil asset forfeiture.

In Section III of the statement, Justice Thomas highlights the history of justification of civil asset forfeiture in the United States. Historically, the British had allowed for statutory forfeitures of objects that were directly involved in a crime. It was first legalized by the United States Congress, however, for matters relating to shipping, mostly as a way to address piracy.

In the modern day, this has greatly expanded as the states and federal government can actually seize property in any context even if it is not directly related to an offense or crime. This proceeds civilly instead of criminally so due process is not required.

In Section II of the statement, Justice Thomas has highlighted that the purpose of civil asset forfeiture has primarily been to punish the owner of the property if they have been supposedly using it for criminal purposes. However, there are no judicial requirements on seizing the property and oversight is limited.

Unsurprisingly, there have been accusations of abuse since there is limited accountability. One such case mentioned was a report that found in the town of Tenaha, Texas that local authorities would regularly seize property from out-of-town individuals who were unlucky enough to be passing through. In another case, a man’s car and all property on him were seized and he was left on the side of the road with no means of communication.

The potential for abuse is certainly very high. As the Justice highlights, this has the tendency to target the poor specifically who traditionally use cash to do purchases. Cash, of course, is easier to seize than credit cards.

Meanwhile, the procedure is highly profitable (the Institute for Justice for that the Department of Justice Assets Forfeiture Fund took in $4.5 billion alone). Since many states permit police departments to keep up to 100% of fund obtained, this shows a very high conflict of interest in civil asset forfeiture cases.

Justice Clarence Thomas’s legal mind has presented an excellent case for civil asset forfeiture reform. He has outlined the great expanses and abuses the procedure has gone through throughout the years and the problems that have been come about.

Fortunately, there is a bill in congress right now called the Fifth Amendment Integrity Restoration (FAIR) Act introduced in the Senate by Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) and in the House by Rep. Tim Walberg (R-Mich.). If the bill passes, it will increase the burden of proof needed to seize property and would eliminate the financial incentives to perform civil asset forfeiture by making all federal seizures go directly to the congressional general fund. This is clearly a bill that is in the best interests of the American people.

For now, it is best to thank Justice Thomas for his dedication to the law and further bringing this issue to the public attention.

10 comments
nehasharma's picture
08/10/2019

Usually, it is good to be a part of this amazing article and I really like to be here on this awesome post.
aliasharma.in/

Webhosting Onedollar's picture
12/31/2018

It is clear, point by point and requesting! I have had a broad extent of assembling in the wake of watching this article from you! I feel it enchanting, your post gave me another point of view! I have analyzed different particular articles about a tantamount theme, yet your article affected me! I believe you keep having staggering articles like this to present to everybody! https://www.webhostingonedollar.com/

aman005's picture
12/26/2018

Gurgaon flaunts the best monetary profit in this world bunches of individuals relocate to here to dwell this place and individuals has possess living style they are living extravagance life our call young ladies office is putting forth extravagance living style. It is truth that this kind of administration can be found by cash affect a rich individual can appreciate the advantage of this administration and our administration is the piece of extravagance grown-up life. In the interim, you will think about yourself as a ruler and might want to insinuate with them.

My name is Neha, I am working in Gurgaon through this blog I might want to tell my work involvement amid the most recent multi month how I have fulfilled the customer require who come to me, when I was called by the customer in Gurgaon then I generally get some information about the place as lodging or home since I am eager to go to the arrangement in inn than the individual room, I don't care to invest the energy in a home consequently I generally lean toward for inn so you may call me whenever in the event that you are in inn.
http://www.callgirlsinaerocity.net/call-girls-in-mg-road-gurgaon.html

DelhiEscorty's picture
12/21/2018

Perfectly sculpted thighs are the evidence of Gods finest creation in the form of picturesque women of our agency, the crossover legs pose they give while seating compels you to fuck them hard many innumerable times, these fleshy toned upper legs entice you to bite them little harshly. The thrilling experience given by Delhi independent escorts are unbeatable, no other girls can give you that emotional, passionate journey, the freedom you get with our women makes you more effortless while enjoying your day. Gentlemen who often go to foreign business tours, or on casual trips can take our steamy ladies along with them, they will be pleased to accompany you, when you get back from your work in the evening, they can even set the inducing atmosphere for ravishing lovemaking. Simultaneously with work, you can experience pleasurable moments of absolute sexiness, charge your sensual senses, do all the experiments your vivid imaginations, our girls will be at your disposal for the whole time period, only the expenses would be yours.
http://www.delhiescorty.com/delhi-independent-escorts.html

DelhiEscorty's picture
12/21/2018

The range of Delhi escorts are not limited, you can plan an artistic date with our girls, treat them like a queen or your lover, they will certainly reciprocate this feeling ten times more. Delhi usual tour can be a great idea to spend romantic time with our fairies, their company will definitely bring back old charm in your life, their holding hand gives you the feeling of completeness. The surprising pleasure will be the spending of the whole night with our enchantress, the position she takes on your warm body is fascinating, the tender finger movement over your erogenous points takes away your breath, mesmerising persona hit precisely on your spirit, thumping in and out also takes the girl to the orgasmic pleasure. These are the kind of services our hypnotising women offer, now it's up to you to carry the meeting further or just put a full stop to your heart wishes, your negligence can harm you in long run of your life, it’s wise to pick the positivity amongst all. Delightful encounter with ravishing hot women surely wins your heart, take you on a ride for seventh heaven, the kind of captivating moments you get will incomparable with any of your life. Think like a reasonable man, go for the fulfilment of your bodily needs, this only gets you the real bliss later, this harmony is all about maintaining an ideal balance among your soul, physique and mind, after attaining this you will not need any pleasure.
http://www.delhiescorty.com/delhi-escorts-service.html

10/11/2018

Justice is the right for everyone. https://www.webtechcoupons.com/offers/vmware/ is the best place to software deal.

shivanidas's picture
10/10/2018

I think that's is the excellent action which are taken by Government and finally we are just think about humanities to increase our nation.. thanks. i hope we will always getting a such kind of informative blog regularly.
http://www.shivanibhatt.com/delhi-escorts-whatsapp-booking.html

Taniyakhan's picture
08/01/2018

I have found this article very Interesting and genuine here, I love to see this post. I really like and appreciated your work. I read deeply your article, the points you have mentioned in this article are awesome.
http://www.mahipalpurcallgirls.com/photos-gallery/

07/12/2018

If you are a rose, I want to stretch my arms, leaving the thorns to make my hands bloody. I promise to take care of you, just like the sites I'm seo and I just believe you have other things to worry about.
http://happy-wheelsgames.com happy wheels
http://geometrydash-game.com geometry dash

kajol78
08/22/2017

I like to read these kind of interesting topics related to justice, thanks for sharing "Justice Clarence Thomas Takes On Civil Asset Forfeiture" publicly, now at http://www.assignmentgeek.com.au/ i can find some dream educational services within my budget range and also in easy terms and conditions.

Pages