Contact FreedomWorks

400 North Capitol Street, NW
Suite 765
Washington, DC 20001

  • Toll Free 1.888.564.6273
  • Local 202.783.3870

Blog

    Obamacare: A Tax on the Poor

    The Obamacare individual mandate will disproportionately affect those who can least afford it. Rather than simply allow people to buy health insurance if they wish to do so, the "Affordable Care Act" imposes a fine if you don't. But for many people without means, the insurance, even with subsidies, will be too expensive. The law amounts to a tax on being poor -- a Poor Tax.

    Obamacare operates, in broad outline, by a combination of several factors:

    Image used under Fair Use, as a repurposed use of a cultural icon.

    1. Expanded Medicaid, the bad insurance for the poor
    2. A whole bunch of rules about what it means to be "insured," typically doubling the price 
    3. The health insurance exchanges, on which individuals are ordered to shop for coverage
    4. A bunch of other rules related to insurance companies, doctors, medical records
    5. For all of it, price controls

    One of the rules says those not eligible for Medicaid who don't get employer-sponsored insurance have to pay for health insurance themselves, or pay a fine of $95 or 1% of their income, whichever is greater. 

    But in the lives of a lot of people who will be subject to the exchanges, the money comes in on Friday and it's gone by Thursday. About a third of Americans have no savings, beyond saving for the rent or car payment. There is no extra money in the budget at all. The only extra money a great many people ever see is their tax refund.

    Individuals and families who make below about $60,000 per year will get "premium assistance tax credits" of some amount, or rather, their insurance company will get money from the government to offset their premiums.

    In any case, the insurance won't be free. People will have to pay something, whether it's $10 or $400, or what the law considers to be affordable. The definition of "affordable" in "Affordable Care Act" is 9% of monthly income. 

    So Obamacare presents people with a choice they can't make: either to spend their last $10, $50, or $400 on health insurance each and every month, or have the government take 1% of their income -- not their refund, but their income -- out of their tax refund. That Poor Tax will rob many people of even the one bit of happiness they pursue enough to catch.

    Many believe the individual mandate is all that holds the law together. But people who can't afford health insurance are not going to buy it just to get a tax refund. If someone can't afford it, they can't afford it. Many already know they won't take out insurance, and more will decide against it once they find out what it's really like.

    Insurance companies are going to find it difficult to collect their premiums, too. People who have to scrounge for their last $50 to pay a premium will sometimes not be able to come up with it, leading to all kinds of collection troubles.

    Smart politicians should want to avoid people blaming them for being hounded by another bill collector.

    The Poor Tax is a cruel policy, one I urge Congress to repeal. If they won't repeal it, they should at least delay it until we see how well the rest of the law works out.

    2 comments
    Christy Witham
    10/01/2013

    I want to sign up for THE TIN CAN PLAN because thats what I can afford and what it will be worth

    lheal's picture
    Loren Heal
    10/02/2013

    You and me both, Christy.

    Pages