This month, a coalition of 21 states suing the federal government asked for an emergency injunction to delay the implementation of the Obama administration’s new overtime regulations while the states fight the rules in court. These new regulations are an attack on small employers and job flexibility and need to be stopped. Many small businesses, which will be most harmed by these new regulations, are not even aware of the new compliance costs facing them starting December 1.
The new overtime rules are “dehumanizing and economically harmful” to them and the nation. Under current Department of Labor (DOL) rules, salaried workers with certain types of job responsibilities and are paid more than $23,660 can be classified as exempt from overtime pay. This classification allows for flexible working arrangements, liberating employees from punching a clock, and reducing compliance costs for businesses who don’t have to track what their employees are doing at any given second.
However, the new rules would more than double this threshold for when someone is required to be eligible for overtime pay, regardless of job responsibilities or the needs of the employee or company. The DOL proposal “will require employers to pay overtime to salaried workers earning less than $47,500 a year, double the current threshold of $23,660.”
As Joseph Metzger of the Leadership Institute notes, this will change the nature of many employees’ working environments:
“That means that we can’t let employees work from home because we can’t track their hours. Employees who leave early to pick up their kids must lose paid hours. An employee who works a late night must take time off that same week even if he would rather have time off the next week. Worst of all, every employee must start punching a clock while every minute of his day is scrutinized.”
The new rules could even result in employees getting paid less than before as employers adjust compensation plans to fit estimated work hours.
Because the regulations take effect on December 1, the states challenging the regulations have requested a preliminary injunction to delay the start date. This is necessary because once the regulations go into effect, the damage is done: employers will have to make whatever changes necessary immediately to avoid fines from the DOL. If the states win their case, possibly years from now, it will be too late.
The result of the state challenge to the overtime rules is still to be determined. There is a strong argument that the DOL has exceeded the law with its regulations, specifically because the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) does not actually authorize a salary threshold for overtime decisions, it was made up by the department. Under the FLSA, overtime exemption is supposed to only be determined by job function (those working in an executive, administrative or professional capacity).
We can only hope that the courts accept this argument and stand up to protect small businesses and employees with flexible working arrangements.