Why Cleveland needs school choice

The Washington Times

Copyright 2002

Saturday, February 23, 2002


Why Cleveland needs school choice

The fate of the Cleveland school district’s voucher program is now in the hands of the Supreme Court, who must decide whether the inclusion of religious schools violates the First Amendment. With religious schools providing the only alternative for most Cleveland students, the importance of the court’s decision for their well-being cannot be underestimated.

According to a study released in November 2001, Cleveland has the

lowest graduation rate of any school district nationwide; not only do

1 in 14 graduate on time but a mere 28 percent graduate at all.

Cleveland schools failed to meet proficiency standards in all

categories, sometimes missing the low 60 percent standard by 30

percentage points, while only 14.5 percent were proficient in all


At Health Careers Center in Cleveland, a specialized school

dedicated to health care careers, only 18 percent of students are

proficient in science. How can a school dedicated to health education
have such low marks in science and be allowed to continue to fail

without external reproach?

In the 1998-1999 school year, John Marshall High School had an

enrollment of 1,853 and 1,909 student suspensions. Infractions ranged

from threatening behavior to possession of drugs and weapons and

other misdeeds.

No wonder parents in Cleveland are outraged at the failure of

their schools. With no choice available to parents, their children

would be imprisoned in schools where the likelihood of graduation is

low and criminal activity is extremely high.

All other arguments aside, school choice provides children with

hope for their future and a prospect for success that could not be achieved otherwise.


Research associate

Citizens for a Sound Economy Foundation


A version of this article was published in The Washington Times Saturday, February 23, 2002

Become a Freedom Team Member

Make an impact in your community by becoming a Freedom Team member!

Join Us Today